Hard vs. Soft Shell Roof Tents – Thule & TentBox Models Compared

Choosing the Perfect Roof Tent for Your UK Adventures

If you’re planning to upgrade your camping setup, nothing transforms your car or van quite like a roof tent. But one big decision can leave buyers scratching their heads: hard shell or soft shell?

At MyRoofTent.co.uk, we specialise in Thule and TentBox rooftop tents—two brands trusted by thousands of UK adventurers. In this guide, we’ll compare hard shell vs. soft shell designs, explore real-world Thule and TentBox models, and share pro tips to help you choose the right tent for your vehicle and travel style.

Whether you’re a weekend warrior heading to the Lake District, or planning an overland expedition across Europe, read on to discover which roof tent is best for you.

What’s the Difference Between Hard Shell and Soft Shell Roof Tents?

Before we look at models, let’s clarify the two main types:

✅ Hard-Shell Roof Tents

These feature a solid, durable outer shell (fibreglass or aluminium) that opens with gas struts or hinges.

Advantages:

• Ultra-fast setup: Opens in seconds – perfect for frequent moves.

• Aerodynamic: Smoother shape reduces wind noise and fuel use on motorways.

• Excellent weatherproofing: Seals tightly against rain and wind.

• Secure storage: Hard shell protects bedding and gear in transit.

• Premium look: Sleek, modern design.

Drawbacks:

• Higher upfront cost.

• Slightly heavier (check your roof load rating).

• Limited internal space compared to big soft-shell foldouts.

✅ Soft-Shell Roof Tents

These use a tough canvas body that folds out over a platform, usually with a protective travel cover.

Advantages:

• Lower cost: Ideal for budget-conscious campers.

• Lighter weight: Easier to lift onto roof racks.

• Roomier interiors: Often expand out beyond roof dimensions.

• Classic camping feel: Canvas walls, big annex options.

• Great for families: More sleeping space in larger versions.

Drawbacks:

• Slower setup (5–10 minutes typical).

• Less aerodynamic when folded.

• Canvas requires drying if packed away wet.

✅ Hard Shell Roof Tents – Thule & TentBox Models Compared

When you want speed, security, and style, hard shell is the way to go. Perfect for regular trips, changeable UK weather, and stealth camping in laybys or campsites.

⭐ Thule Approach (Sizes S, M, L)

• Premium hard-shell rooftop tent with gas-assisted opening.

• Available in three sizes to suit couples or small families.

• Huge windows and skylight for ventilation and stargazing.

• Integrated mattress for all-night comfort.

• Built-in ladder mounts securely to any side.

• Fully 4-season capable – tested in harsh Scandinavian conditions.

Perfect for:
✔️ Serious campers who want all-weather reliability.
✔️ Families needing extra space.
✔️ SUV and 4x4 owners who want a premium look.

[→ Link to Thule Approach Range]

💡 Image suggestion:

Approach L pitched in the Highlands, skylight open at sunrise.

⭐ Thule Basin

• Innovative dual-use design: roof box + tent in one.

• Opens clamshell style for fast setup.

• When closed, acts as a hard-shell cargo box for luggage.

• Perfect for year-round utility.

Perfect for:
✔️ Multi-purpose vehicles needing both storage and sleeping.
✔️ Smaller cars with limited space.

[→ Link to Thule Basin]

💡 Image suggestion:

Basin in roof-box mode on the motorway.

⭐ TentBox Classic

• UK’s favourite fast-opening rooftop tent.

• Gas-assisted lift – open in 30 seconds.

• Hard outer shell keeps bedding safe and dry.

• Foam mattress included.

• Compact profile suits hatchbacks, estates, vans, and SUVs.

Perfect for:
✔️ Solo travellers or couples.
✔️ Quick overnight stops.
✔️ Anyone who hates faffing with poles!

[→ Link to TentBox Classic]

💡 Image suggestion:

TentBox Classic on a VW camper with moody skies.

⭐ TentBox Cargo

• The toughest TentBox model.

• Rugged hard-shell designed for expeditions.

• Compatible with roof racks for bikes, boards, kayaks.

• Opens in seconds with gas struts.

• Built for the UK’s worst weather.

Perfect for:
✔️ Overlanders and explorers.
✔️ 4x4 enthusiasts.
✔️ Year-round UK camping.

[→ Link to TentBox Cargo]

💡 Image suggestion:

Cargo model with bike mounted on top in forest setting.

✅ Soft Shell Roof Tents – Thule & TentBox Models Compared

Soft-shell tents are all about space, value, and classic camping style. They’re brilliant for families, longer stays, and anyone who wants big living space at a lower price.

⭐ Thule Foothill

• Unique side-fold design – preserves roof space for bikes or boxes.

• Compact footprint on the roof.

• Sleeps two comfortably.

• Sets up in ~5 minutes.

• Premium Thule materials and engineering.

Perfect for:
✔️ Small cars or SUVs with limited roof space.
✔️ Cyclists and adventure sports lovers.
✔️ Couples wanting a sleek, reliable tent.

[→ Link to Thule Foothill]

💡 Image suggestion:

Foothill with bikes still mounted on the roof.

⭐ TentBox Lite 2.0

• Budget-friendly introduction to rooftop camping.

• Big internal space – roomy for 2 adults.

• 5-minute setup with fold-out floor.

• Tough weatherproof canvas walls.

• Ladder and mattress included.

Perfect for:
✔️ New campers.
✔️ Smaller cars.
✔️ Budget-conscious adventurers.

[→ Link to TentBox Lite 2.0]

💡 Image suggestion:

Lite 2.0 open at a scenic UK campsite with annex attached.

✅ Hard Shell vs. Soft Shell – Which is Right for You?

✅ Pro Tips for Choosing Your Roof Tent

• Know Your Vehicle: Always check your roof’s dynamic and static load ratings. Don’t overload your bars!

• Plan Your Trips: Quick overnights = hard-shell convenience. Longer stays = soft-shell space.

• Think About Storage: Hard-shell tents can often stay packed with bedding. Soft-shell usually requires separate packing.

• Weather Matters: UK winter camping? Hard-shell is king. Summer festivals? Soft-shell can be brilliant.

• Accessories: Consider awnings, annexes, and ladder extensions for tall vans or SUVs.

✅ Why Buy from MyRoofTent.co.uk?

At MyRoofTent.co.uk, we specialise in Thule and TentBox rooftop tents—the UK’s best brands for reliability, quality, and support.

✅ Expert advice for your vehicle.
✅ UK-based customer service.
✅ Fast shipping and fair prices.
✅ Real camping experience—we use these tents ourselves!

Ready to find your perfect rooftop tent?

✅ Explore our full Hard-Shell Collection and Soft-Shell Collection.
✅ Or browse by brand: Thule | TentBox.
✅ Got questions? Contact us for personalised help—we love chatting about that roof tent life!